'Goodnight Mr Tom' has always been one of my all-time favourite TV Films; I must have seen it a dozen times.
It stars John Thaw and the young Nick Robinson; both of whom (above) were exceptional in their roles.
I heard recently that Thaw had a very difficult childhood. His Mother had walked out on him and his younger brother, leaving them alone with their father who was anything but exemplary; John had been just 7 years old. After a couple of years he and his brother discovered where their mother was living, and one day they dressed in their best suits, and visited her. She told them she wanted nothing to do with them, gave them sixpence each, and told them to go away. They never saw her again.
When I heard this recently (his wife, Sheila Hancock, was reading her biography on Radio 4 Extra), I could only imagine how hard that must have been for the two boys. Being without a Father would be bad enough, but without a Mother even worse. Blatant rejection of that sort, by the one person who should show more love than anyone else, seems heartless and cruel to say the least.
My sister and I had a nice upbringing; two parents, a cat, a budgerigar, and a pleasant home. We had all we needed, but were never greedy. I would say that it was the type of life that ALL children deserve.
Thaw's Mother must have been a very self-centred woman. OK, she may have wanted to leave her husband for someone else, but to abandon her two boys like that was appalling.
If you've never seen 'Goodnight Mr Tom', I recommend that you do so as soon as possible. It broaches much the same 'rejection' subject, which is possibly why Thaw was so believeable. You'll need tissues!

Not all women take to motherhood, my mother had planned to have a large family but after having me she decided she preferred dogs so I was an only child.
ReplyDeleteI prefer Dogs to most people, but I still adore my three children.
DeleteDidn't you have a sister ?
ReplyDeleteSusan Heather is his sister , making comments on this blog.
DeleteYes, my big sister is alive and well, and living in NZ.
DeleteLoved both the book and the movie. Yes - a tough watch in places but a happy(ish) ending. We should take care not to overlook serious mental health issues that can afflict mothers just as they can take anyone else across the range of human roles in life.
ReplyDeleteI haven't read the book. My people had a refugee during the war, and my mother said he simply became one of the family. After he returned to London they never head from him again; my mother was very upset.
DeleteWas this refugee still a child or already an adult and why was your mother so upset ?
DeleteI meant 'Evacuee', not refugee; of course. I think he came to them aged about 12, and stayed for quite a while. My mother treated his as a son, and was upset that he didn't stay in touch.
DeleteVery young , even when going back at 13 or 14 and probably with a difficult life. I have much empathy for war children . Sometimes we should just help and not wait for thanks or news.
DeleteThe film sounds too emotional for me. I prefer comedies.
ReplyDeleteIt's a very humane film, but hard in places. I'm sure you'd 'enjoy' it.
DeleteMotherlove is not genetic. and what about all the children losing mothers and fathers in war ?
ReplyDeleteVery difficult for them too, I would have thought.
DeleteMany women may not be blessed with a natural 'Motherlove', but that doesn't stop the children being deeply affected.
Yes of course , like with all other problems .
DeleteI have seen that film. Yes, it did make me cry but then I cry very easily 🫪.
ReplyDeleteMy mother walked out on us to live with another man but I was a teenager by then, although my brother was only 12. It was a very difficult time for my father as he had done nothing wrong. She just became bored.
Oh dear. So, you shared the same experience as Thaw. Your poor father must have been devastated.
DeleteI love the film and book. Hard to watch at times but very life affirming. Our youngest son watched this at school and he said the whole class were often in tears, teenage boys and girls not frightened of showing emotion. John Thaw was exceptional in this role. Regards Sue H
ReplyDeleteI'm not surprised that they found it emotional. I hope the film was followed by a talk about evacuees etc. It was a strange period in UK history.
DeleteYou reminded me that in my English department we had a full set of the novel, "'Goodnight Mr Tom" by Michelle Magorian. It went down well with the Year 8 classes until after twenty or thirty rounds the paperbacks began to fall apart.
ReplyDeleteI'm quite surprised they found it so appealing; I used to read either the classics, or adventure books.
DeleteI see it was published in 1981, so no wonder I didn't read it at school.
DeleteA great film.
ReplyDeleteYes. Powerful and emotional.
DeleteI don't think Sheila Hancock is late. She is 93
ReplyDeleteOh dear, I thought she was dead. I send her my apologies. I shall alter my text. Thanks for correcting me.
DeleteCro, I will look for this movie... Do you know if it's streaming anywhere? And as for motherhood, I'm sure everyone is not cut out for it, but for some, it's the strongest bond in life.
ReplyDeleteI'm sure it's on You Tube.
DeleteI'm sure you'll find it somewhere. And as for 'motherhood'; I'm sure you're right.
DeleteI believe there are two versions of GMrT, do make sure you watch the one with John Thaw!
DeleteIf one is not suited to motherhood why become a mother? Surely it would be better for the sake of children not to have any children.
ReplyDeleteOne thing is sure, certain children don't deserve the parents they are lumbered with.
DeleteA woman can suffer from postnatal depression and find no connection to her newborn and can continue and reject her child . It's a taboo to speak about it because we have an idyllic view if motherhood. The reality is more complicated. In past times nurses took care of the babies and it is well known that the late Queen Elizabeth was not present for her children. Only Andrew who was her most cherished child has more her attention.
DeleteSheila H is certainly alive with all her marbles. She called Trump a “dangerous, power-drunk, ignorant man”…think she nailed it there
ReplyDeleteCro, I watched the movie today on You Tube. It was great. I can see watching it again. Have you seen Secondhand Lions? It's a really good one too.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you found it. It's one of TV's very best. I'll have a look for SL.
DeleteMrs (or Mr) Anonymous appears to have some very veiled argumentative views. Stand up and put your name to them or back down I reckon, or is it just my interpretation?
ReplyDeleteShe is always like that, and on any subject. I expect she's had a hard life.
Delete